Clemson Study Offers Surprising Conclusion About Payday Loans


You’ve seen these ads everywhere: apply to get a quick $500 to tide yourself over to payday and those funds will be deposited into your checking account within 24 hours.

moneyKnown as payday loans (or cash advance loans) these types of short term lending options have filled the gap for millions of Americans who were short on funds and had a bill that needed to be paid immediately. But, they haven’t been without much controversy: interest rates compete with what the neighborhood loan shark charges and penalties can snag consumers in an endless debt cycle.

As unfavorable that the terms seems with payday loans, a Clemson University study reveals that they are not a contributor to bankruptcy.

Dr. Petru S. Stoianovici and Prof. Michael T. Maloney studied the relationship between payday lending and bankruptcy filings over the period from 1990 to 2006. Using state-level data on the legality of payday lending and on the number of loan stores, the investigators found that neither the legality of payday lending nor an increase in the number of loan stores led to higher rates of consumer bankruptcies.

According to Dr. Stoianovici, he and Prof. Maloney studied the effects of payday-lending legislation and of the numbers of payday-loan stores in early years on personal bankruptcy filing rates in subsequent years. Their study used two different analytical techniques, neither of which found any relationship between payday lending and bankruptcy rates. One of the techniques, called Granger causality testing, is specifically designed to test whether one phenomenon can be said to cause another occurring in a later period.

The findings of the study are consistent with those of other investigators — including Dr. Donald P. Morgan of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and Prof. Jonathan Zinman of Dartmouth College — that access to high-interest-rate consumer credit correlates with improved household financial condition.

An earlier study by Profs. Paige Skiba and Jeremy Tobacman found evidence that making a first payday loan application is related to increased filing rates for a particular kind of bankruptcy called chapter 13, but only for certain marginal loan applicants. The results of the present Clemson study contradict those findings. Importantly, Profs. Skiba and Tobacman found no causal relationship between access to payday loans and bankruptcy filing rates for all payday loan borrowers as a whole. Chapter 13 is a form of personal bankruptcy that was used, in the period studied by Profs. Skiba and Tobacman, primarily by wealthier debtors to preserve their equity in a personal residence. Chapter 13 filings constitute about one-fourth of all bankruptcy filings. To the limited extent that payday-loan borrowers do file for bankruptcy — about 2% of all borrowers — they generally do not file under chapter 13, Prof. Maloney observed.

Commenting on the study, Prof. Maloney said, “This study has important policy implications for legislators considering restrictions on consumer credit, including the interest-rate limitations put forth by President Obama in his economic stimulus proposal. Despite their high cost, payday loans appear to increase the welfare of consumers by enabling them to survive unexpected expenses or interruptions in income. The study shows that, by a key measure of financial outcomes, payday loans are not harmful to their users.”

Most certainly if you are a university student and are considering taking out a payday loan, that option could be a terrible choice for you especially if you aren’t sure that you’ll have the funds on hand to pay your loan back. Loan terms are typically very short from 7 to 14 days and, even with extensions, you could be saddled with a major amount of debt.

Some colleges can lend money to you if needed and at a favorable interest rate if interest is charged. Otherwise, your best option is the time honored “friends and family” lender — someone you know and trust, a person who will not rip you off.

Adv. — Is your family experiencing a financial shortfall this academic year? Scholarships, grants, 529 money, and part time work may not be enough. Learn about private student loans by visiting, your portal for college financial assistance. We have free tools for your download and updated information about current college financing requirements.


end of post idea


Helpful article? Leave us a quick comment below.
And please share this article within your social networks.

facebook linkedin pinterest

Amazon Affiliate Disclosure: is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to The commission earnings are used to defray our cost of operation.

View our FTC Disclosure for other affiliate information.

Categories: College Budgeting